The InvestiGators

Investment Club
Welcome to the web site of Oxford's InvestiGators Investment Club
This site was created in September 1999.
>>> Enter here <<<
|
|
This page of The InvestiGators web site has been visited times.
|
From July 2000 the main content of this website has been transferred to the club's egroups website. The oxfordclub page of egroups can be accessed here (club members will then need to sign in before proceeding any further).
There is also an ezboards message board for use by club members to propose shares to buy and sell. This can be accessed from the Links page of the ezgroups site or it can be accessed here.
Links to egroups sections
Minutes and performance reports and graphs
Year 2000 meeting dates
Year 2001 meeting dates
Links
Read some stuff about the formation of the club
16/4/00
Would you Adam and Eve it - another member has now resigned!
That's 50% of the original 20 members gone after just two years. Whatever happened to the idea that stockmarket investment should be viewed as a 5 year commitment? I guess we just have to hope that the 18 members in the club will be prepared to stay the course and will help us turn the performance round. We certainly need a change in fortunes after the disastrous performances of Somerfield, Reed, Pilkington, Go Ahead, Lloyds TSB, the terrible twosome of the BTF Lite (BA and TATE) etc etc. How could we have picked such a pack of dogs? We'd have done better throwing darts at the back pages of the FT.
9/4/00
The increase to brokerage was voted in by a narrow margin - just 19 votes for compared to a whopping 1 against. Perhaps the tendency to naff off within the first year or two will reduce now. Now that we are into the new tax year we welcome Mike H, Scarlett F and Stuart L into the club. Evan M should be joining as well subject to formal ratification at the April meeting. That will leave one vacancy which we expect will be taken by David H. Once John T leaves at the end of April we'll be back down to 19 members but won't be able to fill the vacancy until the start of the next tax year. We took a deliberate decision to have only 20 members during any one tax year even though Inland Revenue rules allow more than 20 as long as there are only 20 at any one time. This reduces the administrative effort considerably, particularly for the treasurer. It also means we only have to be concerned about the work involved in bringing in new members once each year. As for the recent performance of our portfolio - the less said about that the better. Perhaps the new members will bring us better luck in the new tax year.
16/3/00
A 9th member is considering resigning - the words sinking, ship and rat spring to mind! 4 new members will be joining at the start of the 2000/01 tax year (please bring us a change in fortunes!) and in a bid to reduce turnover and increase long term commitment (this is meant to be for 5 years or more after all) we are having to take drastic measures. We are currently voting on, and look like agreeing to, increasing our exit brokerage charges (we don't apply brokerage at any other time) to make them more punitive in the first two years. This is not meant to be so much a penalty as a means of ensuring new members are committed to medium/long term membership. The proposal is to increase brokerage for members leaving within their first year of membership to 10% (currently 5%), 7% (4%) within the 2nd year, 4% (3%) within the 3rd year and 2% (unchanged) at any time after the end of the 3rd year.
What do you think about this? Please feel free to comment on the Message Board
15/3/00
We started in March 1998 with the full complement of 20 members. Over the past year or so 8 of these have resigned. This includes a run of 5 in the last few months which has meant we have not had any money to invest for many months (nor for several months to come) as every penny has been needed to pay off the departing members.
14/3/00
The treasurer's job is not made any easier by membership turnover. Additionally we have to provide the stockbrokers with a complete new set of members' signatures when new members join. To make such changes a little less onerous we recently agreed that we would cap the total number of members the club could have in any one tax year (not just at any one time) to 20. This means that if a member leaves during the year they will not be replaced until the start of the next tax year. Although this results in less money flowing into the club for the remainder of the year it does mean the spreadsheet can be rather less complex and a revised signature list only needs to be completed once a year.
Some stuff about the club
The club was started in February 1998 after 3 colleagues at a Royal Mail marketing unit in Oxford discussed whether there would be sufficient interest amongst other colleagues for an investment club. Potential members were identified by word of mouth and, eventually, internal e-mail. A meeting was convened and within a very short time 20 people had joined the club and a waiting list of a further half dozen or so had been created. Some of the members had experience of equity investment but most joined the club for (hopefully) education, enrichment and amusement (where have I heard those words before?). I make no comment about which, if any, of these expectations have been fulfilled but recent levels of attendance at meetings may offer a clue. Two members have since left and been replaced by people on the waiting list. Virtually all of the club's members still work for Royal Mail although some no longer work at Oxford but remain in touch with the club's affairs using e-mail, a Lotus Notes database and (more recently) this web site.
It was agreed that each member would contribute an initial £50 of seedcorn money plus their first month's subscription. The subscription was set at a minimum of £25 per month. As the club would adopt the unit method accounting it was agreed that members could subscribe more if they wished. This would be in multiples of £25 (later amended to £5). The rules were later adapted to allow members to make lump sum investments from time to time, if they wished, perhaps to take advantage of price weaknesses.
The first shares were purchased following the meeting held on 8 April 1998. These were BT and Oasis, both of which became two of the most successful shares the club purchased. If only some of the others had been as successful! BT shares are still held as they were purchased for the long term whilst Oasis, bought for recovery after a fall in price, were sold for a significant profit in September 1999 having recovered much of their loss. The club meets monthly in the bar of a hotel on the outskirts of Oxford and with subscriptions totalling around £650 per month, and investment levels of around £1000 per deal, the club is able to make some 7 to 8 purchases per year.
The club currently pursues a policy of investing around 50% in FT100 companies (but within a wide range of 25% to 75%) and the balance in other companies on the main London Stock Exchange or the Alternative Investment Market. This implies an underweighting in large companies but the club's benchmark index is the UK All Share. As the graph shows, the unit price tracked the index very closely for much of the period between the summer of 1998 and the summer of 1999. More recently the portfolio has underperformed against the index due largely to the dire share price performance of Somerfield and one of the two BTF* Lite companies (British Airways). Recent share price falls for Rolls Royce and Go-Ahead have contributed to our woes. Our BT holding helped offset some of this with terrific performance during October and early November due to "the Orange factor". If only we had been quicker off the mark in buying more at £9.50 or less in early October - the Orange takeover announcement came 1 or 2 days too early for us.
To be continued...
A few other facts
- Club commenced: February 1998
- Number of members: 19 (after John T leaves April/May 2000)
- Minimum monthly subscription: £25
- Bank: Barclays (Community Account)
- Stockbrokers: Barclays Stockbrokers
- Membership of organisations: Proshare
- Software used (1): Quicken (bank account and shares)
- Software used (2): Excel (unit calculations)
-
- To be continued...
* The BTF Lite, or Beating The Footsie Lite, is a Motley Fool mechanical strategy involving the purchase of the two lowest priced of the top 10 yielders in the FT30 index, holding them for one year then selling them and repeating the exercise.
October 1999
Enter here
Back to the Top
Since 31 October 1999....